Yogis Welcome; Yogurt Recipe


I saw Martha make some homemade yogurt a few years ago, and I have been wanting to do so ever since.  And now that Etta is eating it, the time had come to finally make it.

Yogurt is a nice was to introduce some calcium, protein and good bacterias into your diet- BUT have you looked at the label?   Quick run frantically to your fridge.   Look real closely at the sugar!  ** I have to say I am not a splenda girl – it gives me headaches and I don’t like the after taste so I dont’ buy artifically sweetened versions, moving on.  Do you know how much sugar is in Yogurt?  The little single serving I have in my fridge, 27 GRAMS, a can of soda has about 39 that is NOT far off.  (especially considering quantity!)

With these types of thoughts brewing in my mind, while surfing (not on the ocean) the other week, I found a blog, called Common Cents Home.  They  had really great instructions to follow to make homemade yogurt. And I decided to try it out.  It worked.  It was easy… but I wanted a thicker yogurt,  (if you look at the label on yogurt, some of them add gelatin as a thickener….).  This first batch therefore become frozen yogurt *bonus!

Now that I saw how easy it was to make, I really started researching how to make thick yogurt and found a great article about how to make Greek yogurt.  So, I followed Common Cents home to make the yogurt then I followed the instructions from the Greek yogurt article to make the second batch.

 I usually start this process first thing in the morning.  Then let it strain through the night.  Takes a full 24 hours basically.

Here is how to do it:

Thick Homemade Greek Vanilla Yogurt Recipe:
Yields about 2 qts+

1 gallon milk (I used whole for the baby, this also makes it hecka awesome creamy, but you can use any type!)
1 cup plain yogurt with live and active cultures… (most yogurts have active cultures, it will say on the label)
1/2 cup sugar (or a bit less of agave nectar, honey, coconut palm sugar netcar)
1 Tbsp vanilla
Pour milk, yogurt, sugar and vanilla into large crockpot.   Blend with whisk.  On low setting allow the milk to increase in temperature to 120 degrees (maybe my crockpot is slow but this took some time for mine, on low about 90 minutes), I was checking the temp every 10 – 15 minutes and stirring each time).  When milk has reached 120 degrees, turn off or unplug your crock pot.  At the end of eight to twelve hours you have yogurt.  Thed longer you wait the more tangy the yogurt becomes.

***If you want, save a cup or so in a pint jar in your fridge at this point as your next starter.
The next time you make it, you won’t have to buy a new starter you can just use yours!

Now at this point you have rather thin yogurt, if that is what you like stick it all in the fridge and enjoy, if you want something a little closer to heaven follow the next instructions.   BTW if making yogurt seems to scary, you can do these next steps with any yogurt to make it extra creamy!)

Thickening the yogurt steps:

Greek Yogurt Recipe Part:

  1. Line a medium to large bowl with cheesecloth, a clean white dishtowel (or I used my large white cotton cloth napkins cause I didn’t have the other two options… just make sure they are lint free, I used a lint roller to be sure) line a large colander with the cloth.  place in your sink.
  2. Dump the yogurt into the center of the cloth.
  3. Bring the four corners of the cloth together and lift the yogurt, make sure you have a good hold.
  4. Over the bowl or sink start to twist the load to tighten the cloth around the yogurt and squeeze out the liquid(whey), it will bead through and begin dripping through the cloth.   (This whey which can be a good byproduct to save and use if you are into Nourishing Traditions  which is a very interesting book by the way.)
  5. Continue squeezing the yogurt under a bit of pressure to force the liquid out.
  6. When the flow of liquid slows down, tie off the top of the cloth just above the yogurt with a twist tie or rubber band (so it is still tight) and place in a colander or strainer over a larger bowl.
  7. Place this bowl containing the colander in your fridge and let it drain for another 2-3 hours, check the bowl it is in and drain.  You need it to be large, you will lose at least half the liquid.   Place back in the fridge and let it drain another 6-8 hours.  You can figure out how long you want to strain it, the longer you strain it, the thicker it gets.
  8. After draining give the bundle one last squeeze over the sink.  Remove the tie… (this is the tricky part it might be good to have a little help so you don’t spill it everywhere) and use a spatula to put the yogurt into a container for storage and or to eat right then and there!  It will be about as thick as sour cream, but sweet and fabulous!
Congratulations, you have Greek yogurt for the price of 1 cup of yogurt and a gallon of milk.

Final Product;
homemade yogurt recipe
how-to-make-yogurt-homemade yogurt
I have made this Greek yogurt recipe several times now, I even tried it with coconut milk which was to die for, you should try it!!
Website | + posts

Cassity Kmetzsch started Remodelaholic after graduating from Utah State University with a degree in Interior Design. Remodelaholic is the place to share her love for knocking out walls, and building everything back up again to not only add function but beauty to her home. Together with her husband Justin, they have remodeled 6 homes and are working on a seventh. She is a mother of four amazing girls. Making a house a home is her favorite hobby.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. >thanks for hosting! love the idea of making the yogurt thick!! I know of a few dip recipes that you can use greek yogurt instead of sour cream, this would be perfect. thanks for sharing..

  2. >I use my crock pot start to finish to make my yogurt, and I leave it plain and unsweetened so that I can add berries or use in place of mayo with out making multiple batches.
    One thing I wanted to let you know, I thicken mine with dried milk, I add about 1 or 1 1/2 cups of dried milk to the initial mixture and it works to thicken it up and still make it creamy. (I tried the gelatin method once just to see, um, not tasty!)

    ~Kelli @ Smidgens

  3. >Wait. Just wait one stinking minute.

    One gallon of organic milk is about $4 and contains 128 fluid ounces +
    One 12 ounce Greek Yogurt from Trader Joe's is $3 + I have it for breakfast every morning = I am going to SAVE SOME MONEY!

  4. >I make yogurt weekly, the kids LOVEt to sweetened their own with a small spoonful of jam. Plus it's a great money saver. The recipe I use: 1gallon milk, 1 can sweetened condensed milk, 2 cup plain yogurt (breyers or yoplait). heat milk to 180; cool to 120 add sw. condensed milk and yogurt. mix well w/wisk. pour into 4 + wide mouth quart jars. put on lids and rings. set in oven with light on for 8-10 hrs. Cool completely. It's wonderful with granola and fresh fruit!
    (more options: for plain but sweeter yogurt add 2 cans sw. condensed milk. add 1/2 tsp clear vanilla flavoring.

  5. Indians make yogurt almost every other day. There is no need to do such huge effort. Boil milk, let it cool for 20 minutes, (it should be a little hotter than warm. Then mix the active cultures (one tablespoon is enough) in the milk. Cover it and put it in some warm place. I normally do it in the night and place it in the oven with only the light on. Dont turn on the oven. Check it early morning, it should be done by that time. Then put it in the refrigerator. After an hour or so, it is ready to be served.

    1. That would work basically you’ve done the same thing in a pot, although I like to do it in my crock pot, since i have it down to a science… and the best part is straining it, to make Greek yogurt- you’ve got to try it. I honestly wouldn’t put the effort in to regular yogurt cuz I can buy that for less money than making it. But Greek yogurt is pretty expensive and i still haven’t had as good as home made.